How to Get a CLUE Report on a House
Ask the seller for a copy, or order one from LexisNexis yourself using the property address and owner's authorization.
Free to compare
Getting the report before you close
A CLUE report lists the insurance claims filed on a house for the past several years, and insurers look at it when deciding what to charge you or whether to offer coverage at all. Since it's tied to the property, not the buyer, you'll need the current owner's help. The seller can request their own copy from LexisNexis and hand it over, which is usually faster. If they won't, you can still order one once you're under contract, since you have an insurable interest in the property at that point. Either way, ask for it early. If the report shows past water damage or multiple claims, some insurers will charge more or decline to write a policy, and finding that out before closing gives you time to shop around instead of scrambling against a deadline.
A clean CLUE report and a bad one can lead to very different quotes for the same house, so it's worth checking before you commit to an insurer. If the house has prior claims, one company might price around them while another declines outright. Comparing quotes once you have the report shows which insurers actually priced in what you found.
What if the report shows claims you didn't expect
A CLUE report can turn up a claim you never heard about from the seller, maybe a roof claim from three years ago or a water damage claim that got fixed and never mentioned during negotiations. This happens more than people expect, since sellers don't always disclose claims that didn't result in a lawsuit or a visible defect. Before deciding the house is a problem, read the report closely. It shows the type of loss, the date, and the amount paid, but not always the full story of what was repaired or how.
If something shows up, ask the seller for repair records or an inspection report tied to that claim. A roof claim with proof of a full replacement afterward is very different from the same claim with a patch job. Insurers reading the CLUE report will draw the same distinction, and some will ask for that documentation themselves before they'll quote a price. Having it ready puts you ahead of that request instead of scrambling for it after an underwriter asks.
Multiple claims in a short window matter more than one older claim, even a large one. Insurers tend to read a pattern, two water damage claims in three years, say, as a sign the underlying problem was never fixed. That reading can mean a higher price, a higher deductible on that specific type of loss, or a decline. A single claim from six or seven years ago tied to a storm that hit the whole area reads differently, since it says nothing about the house's condition now.
None of this means the house is a bad buy. It means the report changes which insurers are worth asking and what you'll need to show them. A house with a clean record can go to nearly any insurer willing to write in the area. A house with claims on file narrows that list, and the insurers still willing to write it will want to see what's been fixed. Getting the report early, before the financing deadline is bearing down, is what gives you room to deal with whatever it says.
Does a CLUE report affect the whole neighborhood, not just this house
A CLUE report only covers claims tied to the specific address, not the street or the subdivision. Insurers often look at the area around the house too, separately from anything in the report itself. If the neighborhood sits in a floodplain, near a stretch of coastline, or in a region with a history of wildfire or hail, that gets factored into pricing regardless of what this particular house has or hasn't claimed before. A clean CLUE report on a house in a high-risk area can still come with a high quote, because the report and the location are two different things an insurer is weighing.
People sometimes read a clean report as a sign the house will be cheap to insure. It's only half the picture. The report rules out one kind of risk, a history of problems with this specific structure. It says nothing about whether the roof is rated for local wind speeds, how far the house sits from a fire station, or whether the area has flooded in the last decade. Those factors come from sources other than the CLUE report, and insurers pull them in on their own.
Flood is worth singling out, since a standard homeowners policy does not cover it no matter what the CLUE report shows. If a prior owner filed a flood claim, it likely won't even appear on the report. Flood claims usually run through a separate flood policy, not the homeowners policy that CLUE tracks. If the house is in or near a flood zone, that's a separate coverage to ask about on its own, independent of anything this report turns up.
None of this changes what the CLUE report is for. It's still the right way to find out what's happened to this house specifically, and it's still worth getting early. It just isn't the only input an insurer uses to price the policy. A buyer who treats it as the whole picture can be surprised by a quote that has little to do with the report at all.
Before closing day
Pull the CLUE report as soon as you're under contract, not the week of closing. If it shows claims, line up repair records now so you're not chasing them while quotes are due.
