Checking a House's Claims History Before You Buy
Order a CLUE report, or ask the seller for one, to see past claims tied to the property.
Free to compare
What a CLUE report shows
A CLUE report lists claims filed on the house for the past several years, including the type of loss and amount paid. It comes from a database insurers report to, not from the seller's memory, so it catches things a seller might leave out.
Who can order it
Sellers can pull their own CLUE report and share it with you. As the buyer, you usually can't order one before closing since you don't yet have an insurable interest in the house. Ask the seller directly or have your agent request it.
Effect on your price
A house with several past claims, especially water damage, can be harder and costlier to insure, even with repairs already made. Insurers weigh the property's claims history separately from yours when they quote a price.
If the history is thin
If a CLUE report isn't available in time, ask the seller directly about past damage, like roof replacement, flooding or fire, and get it in writing. A home inspection can also catch repair work tied to an unreported claim.
A claims history changes what you pay
Past water damage or multiple claims on a house can raise what insurers quote you, even after repairs. Knowing that before closing lets you compare prices across insurers instead of taking the first one.
What to do if the house has past claims
Finding past claims doesn't mean you should walk away from the house. It means you ask more questions before you pick a policy. Start with what caused the claim and what was done about it. A roof replaced after wind damage five years ago is different from a basement that's flooded twice and still floods. Ask the seller for repair invoices or contractor records, not just a description of what happened.
Water damage claims deserve the closest look, because insurers treat them differently than wind or fire. A single water claim tied to a burst pipe that was fixed is often treated as resolved. Repeated water claims, or anything involving mold, can make a house harder to insure at a reasonable price regardless of what's been repaired since. If the CLUE report or the seller's account shows water damage more than once, ask specifically what was replaced and whether the underlying cause, like old plumbing or grading that sends water toward the foundation, was actually fixed.
A history of claims doesn't set your price by itself. Your insurer will also look at the age of the roof and the electrical and plumbing systems, where the house sits, and your own claims history if you've owned a home before. A house with one old claim and new systems throughout can still get a competitive quote. A house with no recorded claims but a thirty-year-old roof might not. Treat the CLUE report as one piece of what an insurer will ask about, not the whole picture.
If a past claim turns up something unresolved, like a roof that was paid for but never replaced, that's worth raising with the seller or your agent before closing, not after. It affects what an insurer will quote and it may affect the sale itself. Getting this sorted out before you're comparing policies means the quotes you get back reflect the house as it actually is, not as it was described to you.
What if the seller won't share the report or the history is incomplete
Not every seller will hand over a CLUE report, and some genuinely don't have one on file if they never filed a claim themselves. That doesn't mean the house has no history worth knowing. Public permit records, often searchable through the city or county, show roof replacements, foundation work and other repairs that needed a permit. A roof pulled from permit records but never mentioned by the seller is worth a direct question.
Your home inspector is another source, even though inspectors don't pull CLUE reports themselves. Water stains in a basement, patched drywall that doesn't match the surrounding wall, or a roof with mismatched shingles all point to repair work that may trace back to a claim nobody disclosed. Ask the inspector to flag anything that looks like past damage, not just current problems, and follow up on those specifically with the seller.
Some states require sellers to disclose known material defects, including past damage, as part of the sale. What counts as material and how it has to be disclosed varies by state, and a seller's disclosure form is not the same thing as a claims history. It tells you what the seller chose to report, not what an insurer paid out. Treat it as one more piece of information, not a substitute for the CLUE report itself.
If closing is approaching and the history still isn't clear, that's worth raising with the insurer directly when you apply for coverage. Some insurers will ask about known past damage on the application regardless of what a CLUE report shows, and answering honestly based on what the inspection and seller disclosure turned up protects you if a claim ever gets questioned later. A thin history doesn't have to delay closing. It just means leaning more on the inspection and the seller's own account to fill in what the report can't.
Before you pick a policy
Check whether the seller's disclosure or inspection flagged any past damage, then ask directly about it before comparing quotes. Insurers price the house's history, not just yours, so settling this now keeps the quotes accurate.
