Can You Look Up Insurance Claims on a House?
Yes, a CLUE report shows a house's claims history for the past several years. Sellers or agents can request one.
Free to compare
What a CLUE Report Shows
A CLUE report lists claims filed on the house for the past several years, usually around seven, including the type of loss and the amount paid. It's tied to the property itself, not the owner, so past claims follow the house even after it's sold.
Who Can Request It
The current owner can order a CLUE report directly, and sellers often share it during disclosure. As the buyer, you typically can't pull one yourself until you have an insurable interest in the house, which usually means you're under contract to buy it.
Why It Affects Your Rate
Insurers look at a property's claims history when deciding what to charge, and when to decline coverage altogether. A house with several past claims, especially for water damage, can mean a higher quote or more questions during underwriting.
What To Do Before Closing
Ask the seller or your agent for the CLUE report early, since a pattern of claims can delay getting a binder in place. If the history raises concerns, get quotes from more than one insurer so a flagged property doesn't leave you with one option.
A house with a rough claims history doesn't price the same everywhere. One insurer might see the water damage claim from three years ago and decline to write the policy at all, while another prices it in and moves on. That gap matters when a lender is waiting on your binder. Checking more than one quote before closing is how you find out which insurer this particular house works for.
What If the Seller Won't Share the Report
Sometimes a seller doesn't have the CLUE report handy or doesn't want to request one before closing. You still have a way to see roughly what you're walking into. Ask the listing agent directly about any known water damage, roof claims or repairs tied to past claims. Sellers filling out a property disclosure form are often required to note major repairs or damage, even if they don't mention an insurance claim by name. Reading that disclosure carefully can tell you almost as much as the report itself.
Once you're under contract, you can request your own CLUE report, and this is worth doing even if the seller already shared one. Reports can take a few days to arrive, so ask as soon as you have a signed contract rather than waiting until closing is close. If the house has a clean history, this step mostly confirms what you already expected. If it doesn't, you'll find out while there's still time to shop the policy around.
A house with no CLUE history isn't necessarily a house with no past damage. Some claims go unreported if an owner paid out of pocket instead of filing, and very old damage may have aged out of the report's usual seven-year window. A home inspection still matters here. An inspector who finds signs of past water intrusion or roof repair work that doesn't match the disclosure is telling you something the claims report might not catch.
If you're buying a house that's new construction or has had one owner for decades, the claims history may be thin either way, and that's normal rather than a red flag. What matters more in that case is getting the dwelling coverage amount right from the start, since a newer house and an older one can need very different numbers to rebuild. The claims report is one piece of the picture, not the whole underwriting decision, and insurers will weigh it alongside the house's age, roof condition and location.
Does a Past Claim Mean You'll Be Denied Coverage
A claim on the CLUE report doesn't automatically mean an insurer walks away. What matters more is the type of loss and whether it was fixed properly. A single wind or hail claim, common in a lot of areas, usually draws less scrutiny than water damage or mold, since those tend to repeat if the underlying problem wasn't addressed. Underwriters are looking for a pattern, not a single incident from a decade ago.
Two or more water-related claims in a short window is the situation that causes the most trouble. Some insurers will decline the house outright once that pattern shows up, regardless of how well you personally maintain it going forward. Others will write the policy but ask for proof of repairs, like a plumber's invoice or a note that a pipe was replaced rather than patched. Having that documentation ready before you apply can be the difference between a quick binder and a week of back and forth.
The amount paid on a past claim matters too, not just the type of loss. A $2,000 claim for a storm-damaged fence reads very differently than a $40,000 claim for a burst pipe that flooded two floors. Insurers weigh severity alongside frequency, so a house with one large claim isn't treated the same as a house with several small ones. If you see a large payout on the report, it's worth asking the seller or agent what repairs followed it, since that context often matters more than the dollar figure alone.
If the history is rough enough that one or two insurers decline, that doesn't mean the house is uninsurable. It means the pool of insurers willing to write it is smaller, and pricing may run higher than a comparable house with no claims. This is exactly the kind of situation where getting quotes from several insurers before closing pays off, since the gap between what one company charges and what another does can be significant when a property carries this kind of history.
Before you lock in a quote
Pull the CLUE report as soon as you're under contract, not after. If it shows past water damage, ask the seller what repairs followed before you let one insurer's answer be the only one you get.
