What Is the Difference Between All Risk and Named Perils Home Insurance?
All risk covers every cause except what your policy excludes. Named perils only covers the causes it specifically lists.
Free to compare
How Your Dwelling Is Covered
Dwelling coverage, the part of your policy that pays to rebuild the house, usually comes as all risk. That means a cause of damage is covered unless your policy excludes it. Check your declarations page to see which form applies to your dwelling coverage.
Where Named Perils Shows Up
Contents coverage, for your belongings, is sometimes written as named perils instead, even when the dwelling is all risk. That means only the causes listed in the policy, like fire or theft, are covered. Read the personal property section separately from the dwelling section.
What Both Forms Leave Out
Neither all risk nor named perils covers flood or earthquake. Those exclusions apply no matter which form your policy uses. If the house sits near water or on unstable ground, your lender may ask for separate coverage before closing.
Effect on Your Price
All risk coverage generally costs more than named perils because it covers more causes by default. When you compare quotes before closing, check whether each one is quoting all risk or named perils. A lower price might mean less coverage, not a better deal.
Two quotes for the same dwelling amount can still cover different things. One insurer might be pricing all risk, another named perils, and nothing on the surface tells you which. That difference changes both what gets paid out after damage and what you pay now. Before you commit to a binder for closing, it's worth comparing quotes side by side to see what each one actually covers for the price.
What Does It Mean When an Exclusion Is Named in the Policy
An all risk policy still has a list of exclusions written into it, and that list does the opposite job of a named perils list. Instead of naming what's covered, it names what isn't. Common ones include flood, earthquake, neglect, wear and tear, and damage from pests. If a cause of loss isn't on that exclusion list, it's covered, even if the policy never mentions it by name.
Reading an all risk policy means reading the exclusions section closely, not the coverage section. The coverage section just says dwelling is covered against all risks of physical loss, or similar wording. The real boundaries of what you're paying for sit in the pages that list what's carved out. Two insurers selling all risk dwelling coverage can carve out different things, so the same label doesn't guarantee the same protection.
Named perils works in reverse, and reading it wrong is an easy mistake to make. If a cause of damage isn't on the list, it's not an exclusion, it's just not covered at all. There's no gray area to argue about after a loss. A named perils policy that lists fire, lightning, windstorm, and theft doesn't cover a burst pipe unless water damage from plumbing is also on that list. Check the exact wording of each peril too, since some policies name windstorm but exclude hail, or name theft but exclude mysterious disappearance.
Endorsements can add perils back or extend an all risk form to cover something it would otherwise exclude, and this matters most for anything unusual about the house. A policy might exclude damage from a sump pump failure unless an endorsement adds it back. If the house has a feature that worries you, a finished basement, an older roof, a wood stove, ask whether it falls under an exclusion before closing, not after something happens to it.
How Do You Find Out Which Exclusions Apply to a Specific House
Every all risk policy carries the same rough shape of exclusions, but the fine print under each one varies by insurer, and some of that fine print depends on the house itself. An older roof might trigger a separate exclusion or a reduced payout for wind and hail, even though the policy is sold as all risk. A home with knob and tube wiring, galvanized plumbing, or an oil tank might carry exclusions tied specifically to those systems. None of this shows up by reading the word all risk on a quote. It shows up by reading the exclusions pages for that specific policy, on that specific house.
The inspection that happens before or shortly after closing is where a lot of this gets decided. An insurer may send someone to look at the roof, the electrical panel, the foundation. What they find can turn into an exclusion, a higher deductible for that one cause of loss, or a requirement to fix something within a set number of days after the policy starts. If the house is older or has had any unusual updates, it's worth asking the insurer directly whether anything about the house itself is likely to be excluded or restricted, rather than finding out after the inspection report comes back.
Age of the home matters in another way too. Some insurers write actual cash value, not full replacement cost, for roofs over a certain age, meaning a roof claim gets paid out at its depreciated value instead of what a new roof costs. This isn't technically an exclusion, it's a payout limit, but it has the same effect on what the reader actually receives after a loss. It's listed separately from the exclusions section, often under loss settlement terms, so it's easy to miss if only the exclusions page gets read.
None of this is something a quote comparison shows on its own. Two policies can list the same exclusions word for word and still treat the roof, the wiring, or the plumbing differently once the settlement terms are factored in. Before signing a binder for closing, asking the insurer plainly what's excluded or limited for this particular house, not just what's excluded in general, is the only way to know what's actually being bought.
Before you lock in a binder
Pull up the declarations page for each quote. Check whether dwelling and contents are both all risk, and look under exclusions or loss settlement for anything tied to the roof or other older systems in the house.
