Can I Get a Home Insurance Refund if I Was Double Insured?
Usually yes. Cancel the overlapping policy and ask for a prorated refund for the time both were active.
Free to compare
How the overlap happens
A new home purchase or a refinance can trigger two policies on the same house. The old insurer wasn't canceled when the new lender set up coverage, or a binder was issued while an existing policy was still active.
Canceling the old policy
Call the insurer that should no longer be covering the house and ask them to cancel as of the date the new policy started. Give them the new policy's effective date so there's no gap and no double coverage after that point.
How the refund gets calculated
Insurers prorate the refund. They return the unused portion of what was paid for the canceled days. Paid for a full year and canceled after two months means getting back roughly ten months of premium, minus any fees the policy allows.
Where the refund goes
If escrow paid the premium, the refund may go back to the escrow account rather than to you directly, which can lower what's needed there. If you paid out of pocket, ask the insurer whether the refund comes as a check or a credit.
Pick the right policy before it overlaps anything
A new policy is the one place to compare dwelling coverage and deductibles against what the house actually costs to rebuild, before escrow pays for it.
Why the overlap might not be the buyer's fault
Double coverage on a new purchase often has nothing to do with anything the buyer did wrong. Title companies and lenders move fast at closing, and the seller's homeowners policy sometimes stays active past the sale date because the seller forgot to cancel it, or the escrow company paying the new policy never confirmed the old one was gone. If the house had a policy before closing, it's worth checking whether that one is still running, not just the one set up for the new owner.
A refinance causes the same problem from a different direction. The old lender's insurance requirement doesn't disappear the moment a new loan closes. If the new lender's insurance agent wrote a new binder without confirming the prior policy was canceled, both could be active for weeks before anyone notices, usually when a declarations page shows up for a policy nobody remembers choosing.
The timing of the refund request matters more than people expect. Insurers prorate back to the cancellation date, not the date the call was made, so waiting a month to catch the overlap doesn't cost anything as long as the cancellation date is set correctly. What does cost money is letting a policy renew for another year while unused. Once a renewal payment goes through, getting that refunded means catching it before the new term is too far along, since some insurers limit how far back a refund reaches.
Proof of cancellation is worth keeping regardless of where the refund lands. Lenders sometimes ask for it when they're reviewing escrow, since an uncanceled policy can make it look like two premiums are owed when only one actually is. A cancellation confirmation and the refund amount, kept together, settles that question without another phone call. If the refund is credited to escrow, the mortgage servicer's next escrow analysis should reflect it, though it can take a billing cycle or two to show up on a statement.
What if the overlap goes unnoticed for a while
Double coverage on a new purchase often has nothing to do with anything the buyer did wrong. Title companies and lenders move fast at closing, and the seller's homeowners policy sometimes stays active past the sale date because the seller forgot to cancel it, or the escrow company paying the new policy never confirmed the old one was gone. If the house had a policy before closing, it's worth checking whether that one is still running, not just the one set up for the new owner.
A refinance causes the same problem from a different direction. The old lender's insurance requirement doesn't disappear the moment a new loan closes. If the new lender's insurance agent wrote a new binder without confirming the prior policy was canceled, both could be active for weeks before anyone notices, usually when a declarations page shows up for a policy nobody remembers choosing.
The timing of the refund request matters more than people expect. Insurers prorate back to the cancellation date, not the date the call was made, so waiting a month to catch the overlap doesn't cost anything as long as the cancellation date is set correctly. What does cost money is letting a policy renew for another year while unused. Once a renewal payment goes through, getting that refunded means catching it before the new term is too far along, since some insurers limit how far back a refund reaches.
Proof of cancellation is worth keeping regardless of where the refund lands. Lenders sometimes ask for it when they're reviewing escrow, since an uncanceled policy can make it look like two premiums are owed when only one actually is. A cancellation confirmation and the refund amount, kept together, settles that question without another phone call. If the refund is credited to escrow, the mortgage servicer's next escrow analysis should reflect it, though it can take a billing cycle or two to show up on a statement.
Before closing, check this
Ask whether the seller's policy on the house is still active, not just whether your new one is set up. Give both insurers the exact date coverage should start or end, so nothing overlaps and nothing goes uncovered.
